In today’s fast-paced digital world, payment applications that allow you to send money quickly and conveniently are becoming increasingly popular. Apps like Venmo, Cash App, and PayPal offer a seamless way to send and receive money, but they come with a set of risks that all users should be aware of. Connor Tomasko, 31, a freelance software consultant in Chicago, highlights these risks and emphasizes the importance of making informed financial decisions.
Convenience vs. Risk: The Payment App Dilemma
Tomasko has always been cautious with credit cards and has studied financial management over the years. She noticed an alarming trend: many people were behaving inappropriately when using payment applications. While we appreciate the convenience these apps offer, often only requiring the recipient’s username to facilitate the transfer, keeping your funds within these apps can be economical. She recognizes that there can be significant downsides to .
The dangers of holding money in payment apps
Tomasko’s main concern is that funds held in payment applications are typically not secured like traditional bank accounts. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), funds within platforms such as Venmo and Cash App generally do not have similar deposit insurance protections, except in certain cases. “Digital payment applications are becoming an increasingly popular alternative to traditional banking services, but they do not offer the same level of protection to ensure the safety of your funds,” said CFPB Director Rohit Chopra. This was mentioned in a recent bulletin.
The estimated transaction value of various payment applications in 2022 will reach a staggering $893 billion, and is expected to increase to $1.6 trillion by 2027. According to a Pew Research Center survey, more than 75% of U.S. adults have used one of the following: Widely used payment applications, 85% of consumers between the ages of 18 and 29 report using services such as PayPal, Venmo, Apple Cash, Google Pay, and Zelle. While the appeal of these applications is undeniable, the risks associated with keeping your money there often outweigh the convenience.
What users should consider
Mr. Tomasko advocates for a proactive approach to financial management. “I always stress the importance of high-yield savings accounts,” she said. But for those in cash-intensive professions like bartending, finding the right place to park your earnings is often a challenge.
Examples of high-yield savings accounts
One of the significant drawbacks of keeping your money in a payment application is missing out on the opportunity to earn interest through a high-yield savings account. Credit Karma consumer advocate Courtney Alev warned against leaving money in peer-to-peer payment accounts for convenience. “While it may be practical to set aside funds to pay for dinner with friends, there are several reasons against this.”
The CFPB’s findings reflect this opinion, and unlike FDIC-insured banks, which protect depositors against the loss of insured deposits of up to at least $250,000 in the event of a bank failure, payment applications typically do not require deposit insurance. It shows that it is not provided. Funds in a payment application may appear similar to funds in a savings account, but they are generally not insured until they are transferred to an FDIC-insured bank or credit union.
Related: Cybersecurity Awareness Month!
When can I offer insurance on my payment application?
Under certain circumstances, payment applications may be able to provide deposit insurance. For example, with Cash App, when a user links their account to a Cash App debit card, their funds are insured. Venmo will cover funds added through direct deposit or check cashing. However, the CFPB notes that funds held in payment applications pose a significantly higher risk of loss for consumers compared to funds held in insured bank or credit union accounts. .
Recommendations for consumers
Given the increased risks associated with storing money in payment applications, the CFPB advises consumers to move their balances to federally insured accounts. Instead of storing your funds in payment apps, consider looking for a high-yield savings account to optimize your personal finances. “Leaving money in these accounts means forgoing potential interest from high-yield savings accounts. Over time, that interest can accumulate significantly,” Alev says. he emphasized.
Tomasko practices what he preaches by immediately transferring the payments he receives from the app. She chooses the “1-3 business day” transfer option when using Venmo to avoid fees. Cash App also has a feature that allows users to automatically transfer funds to their bank account, which she uses regularly. “With Venmo, you’re actively sending money every time you receive a payment,” she shared.
As payment applications grow in popularity, it is important for users to stay informed about the risks associated with storing money within these platforms. Although they offer undeniable convenience, the potential for loss of funds and missed economic opportunities cannot be ignored. By prioritizing financial education and choosing safer alternatives such as high-yield savings accounts, users can protect their hard-earned money and make the most of their financial opportunities. Tomasko’s sage advice: “Always consider the big picture when it comes to managing your finances.”
